Does Changing Prompt Structure Affect AI Outcomes? Here’s What a Study Found

Mar 10 / AI Degree
Artificial intelligence is impressive, but what if a small tweak could make AI responses even better? While most people focus on what they ask AI, it turns out that how they ask matters just as much. A groundbreaking study from Microsoft and MIT has revealed that the format of a prompt alone can change AI performance by up to 40%!

Think of it like baking a cake—you can have the same ingredients, but if you mix them in a different order, the final result can change. The same thing happens when AI models process information based on different prompt formats. Understanding and leveraging this can be a game-changer for anyone using AI for tasks like data analysis, coding, customer interactions, and research.

The Study: Putting AI to the Test

Researchers wanted to understand just how much the formatting of a prompt could impact AI responses. To do this, they tested four popular GPT models (including GPT-4 and GPT-3.5-turbo) by giving them the same set of prompts but changing only the formatting.

The Four Formats Used:

  • Plain Text – Simple, unstructured writing with no formatting, similar to typing in a notepad.
  • Markdown – Structured text that includes headings, bullet points, and bold or italicized text to improve readability.
  • YAML – A structured data format used for configurations, easy for humans and machines to read.
  • JSON – A structured format mainly used for programming and AI-to-AI communication, with key-value pairs organizing the data.
Would AI models interpret prompts differently based on how they were structured? The answer was a resounding yes.
Source: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.10541 

The Results: Formatting Matters—A Lot

The study found huge accuracy differences based purely on formatting. This means that even if the content of a prompt stays the same, simply changing how it is structured can make AI models give better or worse answers.

  • Performance varied by up to 40%!
  • Example: In a reasoning test, JSON formatting improved accuracy by 42% compared to Markdown.
  • In a coding task, GPT-4 struggled with JSON but performed well in Markdown.

These findings highlight that AI does not process all information equally. The way you structure your input can make or break how well AI understands and responds.
There was no one-size-fits-all formatting solution. The best format depended on the task and model being used.
For example:
  • If you’re asking an AI to analyze financial reports, JSON might work better because it organizes numbers and categories clearly.
  • If you’re asking AI to generate long-form text, Markdown might be the best choice because it breaks content into sections and makes it easier to process.
This has massive implications for AI users. Whether you’re a software developer, researcher, or business professional, simply testing different prompt formats could lead to significantly better AI performance.
Source: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.10541 

The Bigger the Model, The Less It Cares—Mostly

  • Larger models (like GPT-4) handled format changes better than smaller ones (like GPT-3.5).
  • But even GPT-4 had a strange blind spot with JSON formatting in a specific coding task.
  • This proves that even the most advanced AI can still have quirks and limitations.

Why does this happen? AI models are trained on massive datasets, but those datasets may not include equal representation of all formats. For example, GPT-4 may have encountered Markdown-style formatting more frequently than YAML or JSON, making it more comfortable interpreting it correctly. This means AI training data plays a huge role in how different formats affect performance.

Can a Good Prompt Format Work for Any Model?

Researchers also tested whether a successful format for one model would work for another. The result? Not necessarily.

  • Even similar AI models reacted differently to the same formatting.
  • It's like assuming that if you speak French, you automatically understand Spanish. There are similarities, but they’re still different languages.
  • This means prompt optimization has to be customized for each AI model and task.

For example:
  • GPT-3.5 might struggle with complex YAML structures, while GPT-4 handles them with ease.
  • A prompt format that works well for natural language processing might not be effective for code generation.

What This Means for You: AI Prompting Tips

If you want to get the best results from AI, pay attention to how you format your prompts! Here are some practical tips:
  • Experiment with multiple formats (Plain text, Markdown, JSON, YAML) to see what works best.
  • For structured data tasks (coding, analysis), JSON may work well—but test it first.
  • For natural language tasks, Markdown or Plain Text might be better.
  • If you’re using GPT-3.5, be extra careful with formatting—it’s more sensitive to changes than GPT-4.
  • Break down complex prompts into clear sections—well-structured input leads to better AI-generated responses.

The Future of Talking to AI

As AI models improve, they may become less sensitive to formatting changes, but right now, formatting still plays a crucial role in how they interpret prompts. This research opens up a whole new field of AI linguistics, helping humans and AI communicate better.

The study suggests that future AI advancements might focus on reducing format sensitivity, making models better at handling prompts regardless of structure. However, until then, understanding and optimizing formatting remains an essential skill for maximizing AI efficiency.

Conclusion: A Simple Change, A Big Difference

  • Prompt formatting isn’t just a minor detail—it can dramatically change AI accuracy.
  • AI models aren’t perfect, and even the best ones like GPT-4 have quirks.
  • Whether you're coding, analyzing data, or just chatting with AI, experiment with different formats to get the best results.
  • AI isn’t just about what you say—it’s also about how you say it.

Final Thoughts

If something as simple as formatting can impact AI performance by 40%, imagine what’s possible with further prompt engineering. Could there be a secret formatting trick that unlocks even better results? Maybe. Or maybe the key is to continuously adapt as AI evolves. Either way, one thing is clear: AI and humans are in a constant learning dance, shaping how we communicate with one another.

So the next time you ask an AI a question, remember: it’s not just about the words, but also the way you arrange them.

Learn More!

If advancements like these excite you and you want to dive into AI, AI Degree is the perfect place to begin. Whether you’re looking to earn a full AI degree or simply learn the basics, this platform makes it simple and accessible:

  • Learn by Doing: Build real AI systems, not just theory.
  • Flexible Learning: Study on your own time, from anywhere—even your phone.
  • Affordable Options: Scholarships, including 100% coverage, make learning AI possible for everyone.
  • Globally Recognized: Earn certificates and optional ECTS credits that are recognized worldwide.

Start Your AI Journey Today!

If you’re ready to become an elite AI developer, now is the time to take action.
To truly harness the power of AI, you need more than just curiosity—you need expertise. The AI Degree program offers a comprehensive, flexible curriculum that lets you learn at your own pace.

From foundational topics to advanced AI development, you’ll gain the skills needed to excel in this dynamic field. Scholarships make it accessible to everyone, and optional ECTS credits provide global recognition.

Start your journey today. Explore free courses, apply for scholarships, and begin building the future of AI—your future. Learn More Here.